×

Bone Cancer Vs Bone Marrow Cancer

05 Mar, 2025

This article is medically reviewed by Dr. Sunit Lokwani, Consultant - Medical Oncology and Clinical Hematology, HCG Cancer Centre, Indore.

Table of Contents

What is Bone Cancer?

Bone cancer is cancer that forms in cells of the bone. Bone cancer is rare and includes several types. Some bone cancers, including osteosarcoma and Ewing sarcoma, are seen most often in children and young adults. Primarily, bone cancer is of two types: primary bone cancer and secondary bone cancer.

Types of Bone Cancer

There are mainly two types of bone cancer: primary and secondary bone cancer.

1. Primary Bone Cancer:Primary bone cancer starts in the bones when the bone cells undergo harmful mutations and begin dividing uncontrollably to form a tumor. Some common types of primary bone cancer are:

  • Osteosarcoma: It develops from bone-forming cells called osteoblasts in osteoid tissue (immature bone tissue). This tumor generally develops in the arm near the shoulder and in the leg near the knee. It spreads quickly to the other parts of the body, including the lungs.
  • Chondrosarcoma: This is another type of bone cancer that grows in cartilaginous tissue. It often develops in the pelvis, upper leg, and shoulder and usually grows slowly, although sometimes it can grow quickly and spread to other parts of the body.
  • Ewing’s Sarcoma: It usually grows in bones but can also rarely develop in soft tissues (muscles, fat, fibrous tissue, blood vessels, etc.). This type of bone cancer spreads quickly to the other parts of the body.
  • Chordoma: It is a very rare type of bone cancer that starts in the bones of the spine. It usually occurs in older adults.li>

2. Secondary Bone Cancer:Secondary bone cancer occurs when cancer from different organs spreads to bones. It is also referred to as bone metastasis.
The cancer cells from the primary tumor break away, travel through the bloodstream or lymph vessels, and accumulate in the bones to develop a new tumor.

Bone Cancer Symptoms

Pain is the most common bone cancer symptom, but not all bone cancer causes pain. Swelling in or near a bone can also be a bone cancer symptom.

Other bone cancer symptoms include:

  • A lump (that may feel soft and warm) in the arms, legs, chest, or pelvis
  • Unexplained fever
  • An increased risk of fractures
  • Hypercalcemia
  • Mobility issues
  • Numbness
  • Unintended weight loss
  • Severe fatigue

Causes of Bone Cancer

While we do not know the exact cause of bone cancer, we do know that certain factors increase its risk. Different risk factors identified for bone cancer include previous history of radiation therapy; history of certain bone diseases (fibrous dysplasia, Paget’s disease of the bone, and endochondromas); certain inherited conditions (Li-Fraumeni syndrome, hereditary retinoblastoma, and Rothmund-Thomson syndrome); history of chemotherapy treatments; and a family history of bone cancer.

Diagnosis of Bone Cancer

Diagnosis of bone cancer generally involves a combination of clinical evaluation, imaging tests, and biopsy procedures. Diagnosis of bone cancer may include:

Blood tests: Blood tests determine the levels of two enzymes, alkaline phosphatase and lactate dehydrogenase. However, blood tests are not typically diagnostic for bone cancer, though they may help rule out other conditions.

X-rays: X-ray imaging is an important testing method recommended for the diagnosis of bone cancer. It can show the location, size, and shape of a bone tumor.

Biopsy: A biopsy is done to confirm the presence of bone cancer and determine its type. There are three types of biopsy: needle biopsy, excisional biopsy, or an incisional biopsy.

Other Imaging Tests: Additionally, imaging tests such as CT scan, MRI, PET scan, and bone scan are recommended for diagnosis, disease staging, and treatment planning.

Treatment for Bone Cancer

Treatment for bone cancer depends on the type, size, location, and stage of the cancer, as well as the person’s age and general health. Here are some options for treatment for bone cancer:

Bone Cancer Survival Rate

Bone cancer survival rates depend on the type, stage, and early detection. For osteosarcoma, the 5-year survival rate is 60%-80% for localized cases but drops to 30%-40% for metastatic cases. Ewing's sarcoma has a 70%-80% survival rate for localized cases, while the survival rate for chondrosarcoma ranges from 80%-90% for low-grade tumors to 50%-60% for high-grade tumors. Metastatic bone cancer has a lower survival rate in general.

What is Bone Marrow Cancer?

Bone marrow cancer develops in the blood-forming stem cells of the bone marrow, the soft tissue inside your bones responsible for producing blood cells. The most common types of bone marrow cancer include leukemia and multiple myeloma.

Types of Bone Marrow Cancer

The most common types of bone marrow cancer are:

  • Multiple Myeloma: It is a cancer of plasma cells, which are a type of white blood cell found in the bone marrow. It begins when abnormal plasma cells form cancerous tumors in bone or soft tissue. When there is only one tumor, the disease is called a plasmacytoma. When there are multiple tumors, it is called multiple myeloma.
  • Leukemia: It is another type of bone marrow cancer of the blood cells. It occurs most often in adults older than 55, but it is also the most common cancer in children younger than 15.
  • Lymphoma: It arises from the lymphocytes, a type of white blood cell that is produced in bone marrow. Although it develops in the lymph nodes, in rare cases it can arise from the bone marrow (primary bone marrow lymphoma).
  • Myelodysplastic Syndrome: This is a rare type of bone marrow cancer that causes the bone marrow to produce abnormal blood cells. The overproduction of abnormal cells and shortage of healthy blood cells can lead to hampered bodily functions.

Bone Marrow Cancer Symptoms

Bone marrow cancer symptoms include:

  • Bone pain
  • Swelling and tenderness near the affected area
  • Weakened bone, which can lead to a broken bone
  • Feeling very tired
  • Losing weight without trying

Causes of Bone Marrow Cancer

The exact cause of bone marrow cancer is often unknown. However, each type of bone marrow cancer has its own risk factors. These factors cause the bone marrow cells to undergo abnormal division and produce cancer cells.

The possible causes of bone marrow cancer include exposure to hazardous chemicals, radiation, and viruses; a compromised immune system; certain genetic conditions and bone marrow failure syndromes; increasing age; smoking; and a history of chemotherapy and/or radiotherapy.

Diagnosis of Bone Marrow Cancer

The diagnosis of bone marrow cancer typically involves a combination of clinical evaluation, laboratory tests, imaging studies, and biopsy procedures.

Diagnosis of bone marrow cancer includes:

Treatment for Bone Marrow Cancer

The treatment for bone marrow cancer, including leukemia, lymphoma, and multiple myeloma, depends on the type of bone marrow cancer, its stage, and individual patient factors like age and overall health.

Some common treatments for bone marrow cancer include:

  • Chemotherapy: Chemotherapy is the most common treatment for bone marrow. It uses drugs to kill or stop the growth of cancer cells. This treatment is often followed by a stem cell transplant.

  • Stem Cell Transplant: Stem cell transplant, or bone marrow transplant, is one of the commonly recommended treatment options for bone marrow cancer. This procedure involves replacing cancerous bone marrow cells with healthy ones to restore the production of normal blood cells.

  • Immunotherapy: Immunotherapy aims to boost or restore the body's immune system so that it can better recognize and fight cancer cells.

  • Targeted therapy: Targeted therapy uses medicines that attack specific components or cellular pathways associated with the growth of cancer cells and control their growth.

  • CAR-T cell therapy: A type of immunotherapy, CAR T-cell therapy involves training the immune system to identify and attack cancer cells. CAR T-cell therapy is found to be effective against certain types of bone marrow cancer. This treatment begins with removing some white blood cells, including T cells, from your blood.

  • Radiation therapy: This treatment for bone marrow cancer involves the use of powerful energy beams to kill cancer cells. Radiation can quickly shrink the growth of myeloma cells.

Bone Marrow Cancer Survival Rate

Bone marrow cancer survival rates depend on cancer type, stage, and patient age. Depending on individual case factors, the 5-year survival rate for leukemia is between 65-70%; for lymphoma, it is around 61-90%; and for multiple myeloma, it is about 40-80%. Bone marrow cancer survival rates have significantly improved in recent times due to the treatment advancements available.

How are Bone Cancer and Bone Marrow Cancer Different?

Bone cancer and bone marrow cancer are two different types of cancer, each affecting different parts of the body with different symptoms, treatments, and results. Through this comprehensive article, we have tried to shed light on various aspects of bone cancer vs bone marrow cancer.

The difference between bone cancer and bone marrow cancer lies in their origins, symptoms, and treatment approaches.

  • Origin: Bone cancer originates within the bones. On the other hand, bone marrow cancer starts in the bone marrow, which is the spongy tissue inside the bones that produces blood cells.

  • Symptoms:Bone cancer symptoms are typically localized and specific to the affected bone. On the other hand, bone marrow cancer symptoms are more systemic, impacting the entire body due to the role of the bone marrow in blood cell production.

  • Cancer spread: Bone cancer tends to stay localized to the bone, though it can spread to other parts of the body, whereas bone marrow cancer often spreads throughout the body early in its progression because the bone marrow is a crucial part of blood cell production, affecting multiple organs and systems.

Conclusion

What is bone cancer, and how it is different from bone marrow cancer depends on their origin and symptoms. Bone cancer starts in the bones, while bone marrow cancer begins in the bone marrow, affecting blood cell production and causing more systemic symptoms. The difference between bone cancer and bone marrow cancer extends to treatment, with bone cancer often requiring surgery and chemotherapy, while bone marrow cancer may involve chemotherapy and stem cell treatments. Understanding the causes of bone cancer, such as genetic factors, helps in determining effective treatments and improving survival rates.

Frequently Asked Questions

No, bone cancer and bone marrow cancer are different. Bone cancer starts in the bones, while bone marrow cancer begins in the bone marrow, affecting blood cell production. They have different symptoms, causes, and treatments.

Bone marrow cancer is not always curable, but treatments like chemotherapy and stem cell transplants can manage it and improve survival, depending on the type and stage.

Survival rates for bone cancer vary. For localized cases, the 5-year survival rate is 60-80%, but for metastatic cases, it drops to 30-40%.

The warning signs of bone cancer include persistent bone pain, swelling or lumps near a bone, unexplained fractures, joint stiffness, fatigue, unexplained weight loss, and fever or night sweats. Consult a doctor if any of these occur.

Yes, bone cancer can lead to death, especially if it's diagnosed in advanced stages or has spread to other parts of the body and the patient fails to show the desired treatment response. However, if diagnosed early and treated properly with a personalized approach, bone cancer patients show excellent success rates.

Bone cancer is detected using X-rays, CT scans, MRIs, and biopsies. Blood tests may also be recommended.

Bone cancer is often discovered through persistent pain, swelling, or fractures. A doctor will use tests like X-rays, MRIs, or a biopsy to confirm the diagnosis.

Early detection of bone cancer involves noticing persistent pain, swelling, or fractures. Regular check-ups and tests like X-rays or MRIs can help catch it early.

The final stage of bone cancer (stage 4) is when it has spread to other parts of the body, making it harder to treat.

Bone marrow cancer, like multiple myeloma and leukemia, is classified by type and progression, not standard stages.

References

Author Bio

Dr. Sunit Lokwani
Consultant - Medical Oncology And Clinical Haematology
MBBS, MD (General Medicine), DM (Medical Oncology)

Dr. Sunit Lokwani is an accomplished hematology and medical oncology consultant who specializes in treating and managing different types of cancer through systemic treatment approaches. He is available for consultations at HCG Cancer Centre, a leading cancer hospital in Indore. His credentials include an MBBS degree, an MD (General Medicine) degree, and a DM (Medical Oncology). Additionally, he is a certified intensivist from the Indian Society of Critical Care Medicine (ISCCM) and the Chinese University of Hong Kong (CUHK), along with DM Certification by IDF.

Before HCG, he was associated with several prestigious healthcare institutes, including Kokilaben Hospitals (Indore), Shalby Hospitals (Jabalpur), Vydehi Institute of Medical Sciences and Research Centre (Bangalore), and CMC (Vellore), among many others.

To book an appointment with Dr. Sunit Lokwani, please click here

Other Blogs